Executive Summary
The candidate worked the cost question in three passes: a read of the material before touching the assistant, a modelling pass with it, and a verification pass against the source documents. First hypothesis was formed at 00:11 and revised once, at 00:34, after a figure failed a check against the rate card.
The pattern through the session is source-first. The assistant was used to structure and to compute, and its outputs were treated as claims to be checked rather than as answers — most visibly when a fuel-surcharge figure it supplied was traced back to the rate card before it entered the working. Where the brief was ambiguous, the ambiguity was carried forward openly rather than resolved silently.
One competency the scenario was designed to probe had no observable evidence: no situation arose in which the candidate had to defend a position against a stakeholder who disagreed, so nothing was seen either way.
Skills Summary
Demonstrated strengths
- Deliberate source navigation. Opened the rate card and the invoice extract before the first prompt, and returned to both when a figure was in question. File selection narrowed as the session went on rather than widening.
- Verification of consequential claims. The one figure that would have changed the answer was checked against its source. The check was initiated by the candidate, not prompted by a colleague.
- Decision ownership. The conclusion sent to the operations manager was the candidate's own, with the assistant's contribution visible in the working rather than substituting for it.
Areas for development
- Eliciting from people. The warehouse lead held a fact the documents did not contain and was never asked. The gap was noticed — it appears in the final message as an open question — but it was reported rather than closed.
- Stating assumptions at the point of use. An ambiguity about which quarter applied was resolved internally and surfaced only at the end.
Chronological Analysis
00:00–00:06 — Orientation. Opened the invoice extract, then the rate card, then the Slack thread, in that order. No AI query in this window.
00:07 — First prompt. Asked the assistant to lay out a cost bridge from the invoice extract, supplying the columns rather than asking what they meant. Evaluator note: scoped request, structure not conclusion.
00:11 — First hypothesis. Stated to the assistant that the rate component looked like the driver. Weak-to-neutral signal at this point: plausible, not yet checked.
00:19 — Assistant supplies a surcharge figure. The response quoted a fuel surcharge that the candidate did not carry into the working.
00:22 — Return to source. Reopened the rate card and located the quarterly band. Strong signal: the check was unprompted, and it was applied to the figure that mattered rather than to an easier one.
00:34 — Revision. Re-ran the bridge on the corrected figure. The revision is visible in the working sent later.
00:41 — Boss pressure. The boss asked for a number. The candidate replied with the figure and the one part still unresolved, rather than dropping the caveat under time pressure.
00:48 — Final message to the operations manager. Conclusion, method, and the open question, in that order.
Skill-by-Skill Observation
Data filtering
- Evidence trail: file opens at 00:02, 00:04, 00:22; narrowing selection across three queries.
- Observation progression: evidence accumulated steadily from the first pass; no reversal.
- Boss interventions: one, at 00:41; the response did not change the candidate's reading of the material.
- Final behavioural pattern: consistently source-first, with the source consulted before rather than after the answer took shape.
Prompt quality
- Evidence trail: three prompts, each narrower than the last; none asked for a conclusion.
- Observation progression: consistent from the first prompt.
- Final behavioural pattern: the assistant was given work to do, not a decision to make.
Uncertainty handling
- Evidence trail: one ambiguity carried from 00:14 to the final message; one open question reported rather than closed.
- Final behavioural pattern: uncertainty was reported honestly, and late. The candidate did not manufacture a number to fill it, and did not ask the person who could have removed it.
Outcome: conclusion vs. ground truth
The candidate's final message attributed the increase primarily to the rate component, with the volume and mix contributions quantified and one lane left unexplained. The scenario's expected outcome names the rate component as the driver.
Where it landed: reached, with one component unresolved. The decisive fact behind that component was held by the warehouse lead and was never elicited, so it is not established by the candidate-visible files alone — those files are insufficient by design.
This section describes where the answer landed. It does not change the observations above, which describe how the candidate worked.
Noise Handling & Hallucination Detection
The Slack thread carried a plausible but unsupported explanation. The candidate read it, did not cite it, and did not treat it as corroboration for the rate hypothesis. The assistant's hedged phrasing around the surcharge did not move the conclusion; the source did.
Hypothesis Timeline
First hypothesis at 00:11, held for 23 minutes, revised once at 00:34 on a source check rather than on a challenge. No further revisions. The revision narrowed the claim rather than replacing it.
Delegation Quality Analysis
Three prompts in fifty minutes. Volume is not the signal here and is reported only for completeness: the assistant was asked for structure and arithmetic, each request narrowed the file selection, and no prompt forwarded the task itself.
Where the candidate judged the assistant unnecessary — the rate-card lookup — they did the work directly. Abstention of that kind is observed competence, not disengagement.
Focus & Off-task Behaviour
No off-task activity observed.
Unverified-answer Delivery
None. The one figure that could have gone out unverified was checked at 00:22, before the answer was composed.
In the candidate's own words
"I was fairly confident on the rate piece. The lane I could not close — I would have wanted to ask someone who was there that week."
Reviewer context only. Self-report is not an assessment input and did not move any observation above.